With emma thompson, christopher lloyd, eileen atkins, audra mcdonald. Examining six medicalethics dilemmas best doctors 2008. First of all it is necessary to say that wit is an american television movie directed by mike nichols in 2001. Analysis of the movie wit, nurse susie s character bartleby. Kelekian discussed the treatment options, he never gave professor vivian a choice, and just made the decision for her, and took her consent too quickly. The ethical principles of the movie wit 733 words cram. Girl, interrupted, novel by susanna kaysen the authors autobiographical tale of a year spent in a mental hospital in the 1960s. The dilemmas of life producing plenty of bad decisions. I just watched rudderless and i gotta say, the movie played out pretty much like begin again another movie i love until some deep ethical issues were pointed out. Todays physicians are subject to numerous competing pressures, rooted in both time and money, perhaps to an extent theyve never experienced before. The authors have faced all eight of the clinical scenarios in this paper in their routine clinical practice. But the film is so much more than these isolated matters.
He wrote and directed seven productions for yorba linda civic light operas youth theater. An engaging narrative of the discovery of specific staining techniques, treatment for diphtheria and the first syphilis drug. Wit 2001 nrin netherlands research integrity network. This paper highlights some of the ethical dilemmas that face practising clinicians in their everyday life and restates how useful the general medical council guidance is to make appropriate decisions. Vivian reluctantly consents to the therapy and agrees to a degrading.
Harvey kelekian, and jason posner, is morally viewed characters because of their discussions with the patient. An analysis abstract wit is a movie about a woman dying of cancer. A renowned professor is forced to reassess her life when she is diagnosed with terminal ovarian cancer. Japanese physicians should be able to recognize aspects of medical. Wit the film wit shed light on events that sadly do occur in a hospital setting.
She is very perceptive of her surroundings and questions things she does not understand. This 41page guide for wit by margaret edson includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis covering 17 chapters, as well as several more indepth sections of expertwritten literary analysis. The dilemma of the movie wit essay 1145 words bartleby. Doctors often fail to provide patient centered care. Upon watching the film entitled the wit by margaret edson, i have come to realize that this appears to be a. Yes, a lot of the doctors today indulge in unethical practices but we dont pass out of medical colleges aiming to become such a doctor. The recurring theme throughout the movie is the nurses role as the compassionate, caring individual who humanizes the main character. Adapted from margaret edsons 1999 pulitzer prize winning play, wit tells the tragic story of professor vivian bearing emma thompson. Click here to visit our frequently asked questions about html5 video. Racism remember the titans 2000 deals with issues of bigotry, tolerance, racism, respect, responsibility, fairness and citizenship. Doctors, nurses, and other staff members in the midst of work, forget that their patients are human. Medical ethics is a branch of ethics which pertains to medical practice. In the film, nurse susie showed compassion whenever vivian was feeling down and depressed. What are some good movies that raise some important.
Medical films tend to lean toward thrillers, comedies, dark humor or based upon true stories such as documentaries. The matriarchs of both families are similar in many aspects. Ethical problems in clinical practice postgraduate. In the assigned movie wit, the main role is of vivian bearing which is a college professor who teaches a course in english. To get a sense of what sorts of ethical problems patients and doctors are now facing, new york identified six real cases from city hospitals representing a variety of issues and asked a panel of. Deals with bioethical issues including brain scanning, and also issues such as privacy and freedom. Bearing goes through the journey, the audience sees her become. Films that address ethical issues can often motivate those who may not have otherwise known about a problem to. It was shown at the edinburgh film festival and the. The movie wit introduces us to a woman by the name of vivian bearing, who is an english professor.
Bearing goes through many emotions as she grows and develops as a character. Besides exposure to difficult ethical dilemmas in a safe environment, this teaching process gave them the opportunity to build their own capacity for managing difficult cases, breaking bad news and facing dying. Medical economics consulted doctors and healthcare experts to explore the pushpull of four ethical, financial, and logistical dilemmas that doctors must navigate in 2014and beyond. Ethics in movies assignment for this group assignment 4 members per group, you are required to pick and watch any one 1 of movies from the list given. Todays physicians have to deal with electronic medical records, smartphones, and social media. She teaches 17th century english poetry and specializes in interpreting sonnets.
It has attracted not only enormous critical acclaim but widespread interest among physicians. In the movie wit, students recognised many issues from palliative medicine and started to gain understanding of their importance. In the beginning of the film, vivian bearing, a professor is diagnosed with stage four ovarian cancers which are metastasizing. Movies about ethical issues can often do something much more exciting than keep people in their seats for the two or so hours the film lasts.
Ethics is about judgment, which is rarely black and white. Emma thompson and mike nichols adaptation of margaret edsons intellectual antiintellectual play wit, which won the 1999 pulitzer prize, movingly explores a tough but emotionally homeless scholars confrontation with a lifethreatening illness. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides for challenging works of literature. Unfortunately, the heroine of wit, who is a professor, was not counseled about end of life issues and was not given the right for patient. The concepts learned in our nursing courses on caring and professionalism were critical to keep in mind while watching and. A lot of doctors forget that there are people in those bodies they take care of. When analyzing the movie wit in an ethical perspective, it shows that the ethical principles were covered poorly. Dr harvey kelekian christopher lloyd, vivians consultant. Using movies to teach professionalism to medical students ncbi. The main goals of my paper are to discuss this film with some details and express my own opinion about this film. There is already a wealth of knowledge out there in regards to ethical issues, and there are so many resources to help doctors in such situations.
In the movie wit, nurse susies character in this movie was essential to display the importance of having the emotional support between medical professionals and the patients. Top ethical challenges for physicians medical ethics. Furthermore, the death of vivian bearing in the play wit by margaret edson plays a role by teaching vivian how to use compassion. It also made them reflect on their attitudes towards life, death and dying. Im a nursing student and currently taking professional issues in nursing. Movies dealing with serious morality or ethical issues. What do you think are 5 ethical issues facing physicians today. Ironically, one of her doctors, jason, is a former student and now a budding researcher in his own profession, having been inspired by vivians uncompromising scholarship. He taught the importance of showing compassion and sensitivity towards their patients, which in turn will make them better doctors.
Girl, interrupted movie, 1999, starring winona ryder and angelina jolie vhs or dvd format. This movie showed a lot of ethical issues that are truly happening. They are right because the results will go toward the endearment of the scientific community. In relating and adjusting to the results of her sonogram of her.
In the play wit by margaret edson, the relationships between the doctors are in need of examination. What then is the reason that many doctors cannot practise ethically in contemporary india. Do you also wrestle with some of these tough situations. Its a story about a woman vivian bearingplayed by emma thompson dealing with the illness, treatment, and inevitable death from ovarian cancer. Films that address issues of gender, transgender, sexual orientation, nationality, race, etc. This resource is a smallgroup activity aimed to facilitate discussions after a viewing of the emmy awardwinning movie wit. A window on tensions in clinical trials bioethicsbytes. This list of the 25 best medical films ever made include all those genres, and includes health issues such as aids, cancer, mental illnesses and pregnancy.
Ethics in medicine is a daily challenge for physicians, who must deal with issues like access to care, genetic testing and care vs. American history x 1998 a classic movie about racism, hate, anger, and reconciliation. She is able to reflect back on her life after she was diagnosed with stage 4 ovarian cancer. The film wit provided me with a unique opportunity to understand a patients perceptions of the health care system while fighting cancer. Movies about medical ethics student doctor network. Such technology brings issues about confidentiality and boundaries of the doctor patient relationship to the fore. Going beyond the physical practice of medicine, ethics of medicine also includes. A panel of experts in medical ethics highlight the top challenges for physicians, plus resources to aid in decisionmaking and delivery of patient care. Vivian, a ruthless scholar of 17th century english poetry, is diagnosed with advanced stage 4 metastatic ovarian cancer. Starring emma thompson as professor vivian bearing, who undergoes experimental treatment for stage four metastatic ovarian cancer, the 2001 film is based on the 1998 play by margaret edson. The facilitators guide and accompanying materials will enable faculty to lead small groups to effectively discuss breaking bad news, death and dying, donotresuscitate dnr orders, and clinical research trials after showing the movie. Anna fitzgerald looks to earn medical emancipation from her parents who until now have relied on their youngest child to help their leukemiastricken daughter kate remain alive. Cameron diaz, abigail breslin, alec baldwin, walter. The physician manipulated the situation when he informs professor barrings of her.
What are some good movies that raise some important ethical dilemmas. Kelekian, the head doctor, tells her she has stage four ovarian. In the film wit, the major ethical dilemma presented in the film, were the treatment option that. They walk the ethical line between taking risks with vivians wellbeing and acquiring knowledge that might benefit. If you are faced with an ethical dilemma, you can look to a number of medical bodies to help you find a solution, including the gmc and bma. Bioethics at the movies 2009 and the picture of health. From an ethical standpoint, there has probably never been a more difficult time to be a physician than in todays climate of rising insurance costs, malpractice claims, end of life matters, elective surgical procedures, social media and pharmaceutical advertising. Ethical dilemmas and difficult issues are a part of physicians lives, and some decisions continue to haunt doctors. A shrewd and triumphant retooling of margaret edsons 1997 pulitzer prizewinning play, wit tempers its harrowing tale of an english literary scholars fierce fight against ovarian cancer with. I would probably want her as my teacher because i know that although she is.
Wit is a 2001 american television movie directed by mike nichols. Wit teaching about death, dying, clinical trials, and. I enjoyed ex machinas duelling ethicalmoral dilemmas ai to pleasure the body vs ai to pleasure the mind. Her classes are very rigorous but she is dedicated to teaching and wants to see her students succeed. The wit film is a 2001 american television movie directed by mike nichols. It was based on the 1999 pulitzer prize winning play of the same title by margaret edson. Im going to write a reaction paper on the movie wit that i have watched recently. Ira byock, looks at dying with dignity and the need for care at the end of life as he states the need for care is not undignified. For physicians practicing in the digital age, ethical clinical practice has never been more complicated. To find out what doctors would do if faced with those difficult situations, medscape surveyed physicians attitudes about some of the most frequent and wrenching ethical issues of our time.
Kelekian, the head doctor, tells her she has stage four ovarian cancer she goes into a state of oblivion and questions his use of words such as insidious, rather than the issue at hand wit, 2001. In this book, i have resisted the temptation to simply list the gory details and ask doctors to become more honest. The research integrity topics discussed in this movie are. Using movies to teach professionalism to medical students. It is a powerful drama that chronicles the last few months of her life. The teleplay by nichols and emma thompson is based on the 1999 pulitzer prize winning play of the same title by margaret edson the film was shown at the berlin international film festival on february 9, 2001 before being broadcast by hbo on march 24. At the same time, it ruthlessly deconstructs the modern medical research establishment. The main thing i remember is that the doctor learned and taught that patients were people. Wit, 2001 according to miller and brody 2003, the rolerelated obligation of a researcher is to conduct clinical trials in a way that produces valid results in a timely manner. Students have recognised the following medicoprofessional and ethical dimensions of the movie. In the movie wit, the wounded storyteller, vivian bearing narrates a heart clenching.
302 1420 169 178 19 140 1459 215 81 706 1455 670 884 1603 787 1166 949 665 1364 524 1224 273 784 1185 238 1640 828 1105 923 185 1506 518 1016 786 939 422 456 1310 936 84 612 1479 73 1273